Co-op Bank leads Bid to Stabilize Small Businesses against Loan Defaults

There is a timely effort by banks to cushion small businesses and stave off mass loan defaults. This comes after a three-pronged hit from the weakening shilling, dollar dearth and rising interest rates.

Convergence of these headwinds has ripped up the playbook of most lenders as they move to stave off a resurgence in non-performing loans in an economy where businesses and individuals have also been hit with new taxes.

Banks are fretting that the progress, which had been achieved in offering accommodation to business customers following the Covid-19 pandemic disruptions may go under the drain in the emergence of new and unforeseen challenges in the operating environment.

They are now reaching out to small and medium-sized enterprises (SMEs) with support packages including extending repayment periods and connecting some with affordable suppliers of imported goods.

Lenders say they are emboldened by the statistics that showed that of the 6,572 MSME loans valued at Sh122.5 billion that were restructured last year, over 90 per cent were being serviced.

“With elevated repayment in terms of ticket sizes of repayment, that is actually an extra burden on the customer. But with an elongated period in terms of loan tenors, that supports customers,” says the Kenya Bankers Association.

The consistent slump of the Kenya shilling against world majors, which has shed over 19 per cent of its value against the dollar since January, has for instance thrown into disarray many small businesses dependent on imports.

Electricity and fuel prices have also been rising, partly on the State’s stance to cut subsidies and increase taxes, catching many businesses on the wrong foot.

The weakening of the shilling and rising energy prices have coincided with a rise in the cost of credit, piling significant pressure on the margins and cash flows of small businesses.

The introduction of new taxes on both individuals and businesses has played a double-edged sword role, increasing operating costs while also weakening the purchasing power of consumers.

Bankers say these shocks have been especially damaging because they were mostly unexpected and have all converged at nearly the same time.

Lenders are worried that most borrowers if left on their own, will struggle and default in servicing their loans, heightening the spike in bad debts across the banking system.

Their interventions have come to the aid of many small businesses such as car dealers, clothing and footwear shops and manufacturers who source inputs abroad and have had to adjust their budgets upwards or cut the size of imports, even as access to dollars remains scarce.

“We are supporting MSMEs on cash flow-based restructures, by matching their loan repayments with their current business income, free of restructuring fees, on a case-by-case basis,” says Mr Gideon Muriuki, managing director at Co-operative Bank of Kenya.

Central Bank of Kenya (CBK) data already indicates a steady rise in loan defaults. Gross non-performing loans—the amount of loans on which interest and principal have not been paid for at least three months— hit Sh586.2 billion in July, a Sh10.1 billion jump from the previous month.

Lenders had endured a rise in defaults for five consecutive months to May when the figure peaked at Sh592.6 billion before cooling to Sh576.1 in June.

At Sh586.2 billion, borrowers defaulted on 14.7 per cent of the Sh3.975 trillion that banks had issued as loans by the end of July. Lenders have reacted by increasing the provisioning for loan defaults.

The Head of Legal Services at Kenya Mortgage Refinance Company Elisha Nyikuli, the Director, Corporate & Institutional Banking at Co-op Bank Jackie Waithaka & the CEO National Co-operative Housing Union Mary Mathenge at a recent stakeholder’s meeting.

 

Banks’ weighted average interest rates have been rising over time to hit 13.5 per cent in July— the highest since March 2018 when the figure was at 13.49 per cent. This has been in line with the rising Central Bank rate.

Lenders, armed with the lessons learnt from managing COVID-19 shocks, reckon that working with customers early enough is likely to forestall a deterioration in the business performance of small firms.

Co-op Bank has been facilitating face-to-face meetings between Kenyan businesses and their sourcing suppliers abroad, for more structured negotiations.

Such engagements in countries such as Malaysia and Vietnam have helped SMEs improve the way they handle the sourcing of imports.

The tours, complemented with free expert financial literacy and coaching webinars have helped address issues such as cash flow and financial management, tax and online marketing.

“We regard today’s SMEs as the multinational corporations of tomorrow, and, therefore, commit significant resources and in addition partner with institutions that have domain expertise in enterprise development such as International Finance Corporation to support their growth,” says Mr Muriuki.

Lenders have also ramped up non-financial services activities that largely entail the hosting of customer engagement forums where expert-guided discussions are held to prepare SMEs for coping with emerging needs.

I&M Bank says it has enhanced support to small businesses in the form of unsecured business loans, local purchase order financing, invoice discounting and stock financing while also standing ready for restructures for firms that run into servicing problems.

“We now proactively engage one-on-one with such customers who are facing challenges to ensure they are running a sustainable business,” says Shameer Patel, head of retail banking at the I&M.

Banks are also increasing their focus on State-backed credit guarantee schemes to offer working capital loans at concessional rates.

KCB Bank Kenya and the Swedish International Development Cooperation Agency in August rolled out a Sh1 billion guarantee scheme for de-risking SMEs in their efforts to access credit

“The seven-year guarantee facility will enable the bank to strengthen its commitment to financing SMEs which continue to experience challenges, especially with access to affordable credit,” said KCB.

Source: Business Daily

The new tax proposal will push away gaming companies from Kenya, if its implemented

The Ministry of Finance is seeking to reintroduce excise duty on betting at a rate of 20 percent of the amount staked.

This means total taxes would exceed 86.5 percent, which could again bring closure of some betting firms due to the unfavorable working environment.

 

In turn, Kenya would be left without great income and thousands of people that work in this industry would lose their jobs.

Here is a list of all the taxes that betting companies would have to pay:

  • 20 percent Excise Tax on betting stake
  • 1.5% Digital service tax on betting tax
  • 15 percent Betting Tax
  • Tax on winnings 20 percent
  • Income tax 30 percent

Additionally, the return on investment in Kenya through the payment of profits/repayment of loans would be subject to additional taxation in Kenya, which would lead to the situation that due to the applied tax policy, doing business in Kenya would not be commercially viable.

 

Reintroducing excise duty on betting, total taxes would exceed 86,5 percent. The negative effects of stringent measures could again bring closure of some betting firms

Foreign companies describe the Kenyan market as an over-taxed and unfair operating environment.

The companies in the industry are already paying high fees, and additional taxes are being proposed, which do not exist in Europe or America.

In England, the tax on the difference is 20 percent, and there is no tax on winnings or stake, Kenya would be one of the few countries in the world to adopt this model of taxing the gambling industry.

Excise duty on betting was introduced in 2019 but was removed in July last year.

 

One of the reasons behind removing the tax was that the high level of taxation had led to punters placing bets on foreign platforms that were not subject to tax and thereby denying the government revenue.

Parliament scrapped the excise tax saying that it is meant to reverse the negative effects of stringent measures that included the closure of some well-known betting firms.

That closure led to job losses for hundreds of Kenyans and a revenue gap to the taxman who had annually collected billions of shillings in taxes from the betting industry.

Gaming companies are big sponsors of Kenyan sports and generally have a great impact on the community.

They have especially stood out with donations during the coronavirus pandemic.

Wallace Kantai lands new job at the Central Bank of Kenya 6 months after quitting NTV

Wallace Kantai left NTV after falling out with the management. The former NTV business editor was a victim of the convergence model implemented by NMG last year.

Nation’s business media platforms – print, digital and TV were all converged into one and put under the Business Daily. The transition was hard for journalists from Daily Nation and NTV who expressed their displeasure with the move.

Wallace Kantai

Wallace Kantai decided to quit his job altogether following the move by NMG. His whereabouts remained unknown until on Friday November 3rd.

Wallace gets CBK job

The Central Bank of Kenya (CBK) has appointed Wallace its head of communications. CBK announced Wallace’s appointment in a statement issued to the press.